SHADOWS ON THE WALL | REVIEWS | NEWS | FESTIVAL | AWARDS | Q&A | ABOUT | TALKBACK
Shadows Film FestShadows off the beaten path
Indies, foreign, docs and shorts...

On this page: THE COUNT OF MONTE CRISTO | THE GIRL WITH THE NEEDLE | HOW TO MAKE MILLIONS BEFORE GRANDMA DIES

< <
F O R E I G N > >

See also: SHADOWS FILM FESTIVAL | Last update 24.Dec.24

The Count of Monte Cristo   Le Comte de Monte Cristo
Review by Rich Cline | 4/5

All We Imagine as Light
dir-scr Alexandre de La Patelliere, Matthieu Delaporte
prd Dimitri Rassam
with Pierre Niney, Bastien Bouillon, Anais Demoustier, Anamaria Vartolomei, Laurent Lafitte, Pierfrancesco Favino, Patrick Mille, Vassili Schneider, Julien De Saint Jean, Julie De Bona, Adele Simphal, Stephane Varupenne
release Fr 28.Jun.24,
UK 30.Aug.24, US 20.Dec.24
24/France Pathe 2h58


CANNES FILM FEST



Is it streaming?

bouillon, demoustier and ninney
Lavishly produced, this French adaptation of the 1846 Alexandre Dumas novel is thrillingly entertaining thanks to its attention to character detail. And it maintains a snappy pace over nearly three hours. An epic tale of vengeance, this is also a still-timely tale about the importance of seeking out justice, no matter how long it takes. It's a sharply written and directed adaptation with some surprises up its sleeve.
In 1815 Marseille, after an act of gallantry, shipmate Edmond (Niney) is made captain of his sailing vessel, which allows him to marry his beloved Mercedes (Demoustier). But he's suddenly arrested on false charges and sent to a barbaric island prison. After 14 years, he escapes with the help of fellow prisoner Abbe (Favino) and vows to get revenge against his accuser (Mille), the close friend (Bouillon) who betrayed him and the prosecutor (Lafitte) who cruelly locked him up. Assuming Abbe's identity as the Count of Monte Cristo, Edmond sets his elaborate plan into motion.
The escape Edmond plans with Abbe is a very long game indeed, so over the course of more than a decade, Edmond has a chance to learn everything he can from this educated man. And with his new identity, he can set about not merely righting wrongs but giving the villains in his life a taste of their own medicine. To do this requires young accomplices (Vartolomei, De Saint Jean and Schneider) both knowing and unwitting, plus some elaborate Mission: Impossible style disguises and a tricked-out chateau befitting a Bond villain.

Ninney is terrific as Edmond, both the lovelorn wronged man and the confident vigilante. In both cases, his underlying feelings emerge beneath the surface. But because he is in control, he quietly watches the others squirm as he cleverly confronts them with their transgressions. Then he needs to learn a lesson as well. Each actor finds nuance in their role, with particularly string scenes between Ninney and Demoustier, as Mercedes' story arc has its own emotional kick.

This is a wonderful, time-honoured story told here in a way that's brisk but also marvellously unrushed, packed with characters who continually pull us in deeper. The way Edmond smartly plays his enemies by sidling up to them and plotting intricately is exciting to watch, while the drama is hugely involving because the characters are so strong. And there are heart-stopping moments that confront ideas of mercy and forgiveness with a bleak complexity.

cert 12 themes, language, violence 18.Dec.24


The Girl With the Needle   Pigen Med Nålen
Review by Rich Cline | 4/5     MUST must see SEE
The Girl With the Needle
dir Magnus von Horn
scr Line Langebek Knudsen, Magnus von Horn
prd Malene Blenkov, Mariusz Wlodarski
with Vic Carmen Sonne, Trine Dyrholm, Besir Zeciri, Ava Knox Martin, Joachim Fjelstrup, Tessa Hoder, Ari Alexander, Benedikte Hansen, Soren Saetter-Lassen, Per Thiim Thim, Dan Jakobsen, Anna Tulestedt
release US 6.Dec.24,
UK 10.Jan.25
24/Denmark 2h03

CANNES FILM FEST
TORONTO FILM FEST



Is it streaming?

sonne
Shot in black and white with an extraordinary visual sensibility, this Danish drama is inspired by true events, taking on a current topic in timeless style. Director Magnus von Horn creates unusually vivid characters who have complex reactions to events that relate to birth, death, disability and the moral fallout from war. So emotions run high, and the film often begins to feel more like horror than drama.
In 1910 Copenhagen, Karoline (Sonne) is struggling to find work without proof of her husband's death. Indeed, Peter (Zeciri) has survived the war, although he's been seriously injured. And Karoline has a wealthy new boyfriend Jorgen (Fjelstrup), who is forbidden from marrying her. Then when she tries to end her pregnancy, she meets Dagmar (Dyrholm), who takes in women with unwanted babies. Unable to pay her bill, she begins working with Dagmar and her daughter Erena (Martin). What Karoline discovers in Dagmar's house is shocking, as is the way she opts to navigate the situation.
Stunning sequences fill the screen, including an extended visit to a creepy war-themed circus where Karoline is all too familiar with the freak who's on show. Her journey through this narrative is a properly overwhelming odyssey that circles around the enormous issues in her life, including the birth of her illegitimate child, the return of her husband and a confrontation with actions that thoroughly boggle her mind (and ours too). Through all of this, we are right with her, guided by Michal Dymek's astonishing cinematography.

Sonne is fully invested in Karoline's inner life, so her thoughts and feelings are clear even though she doesn't say much. Each person she interacts with feels like a challenge, bringing unexpected twists into Karoline's situation that require enormously thorny decision-making. Her scenes with the wonderfully opaque Dyrholm are particularly well-played, packed with nuance and chilling details. Zeciri gives Peter a strikingly humane soul, while Martin's young Erena is fascinating in her unpredictability.

"I only did what you're too scared to do," Dagmar says sternly to men who dare to judge her. "You should give me a medal." At the centre of this film is the way a male-dominated society uses and discards women in a range of cruel ways. This is expressed throughout the story, emerging in each event Karoline faces. Of course, this also makes the film unusually grim at times. But the script finds lovely sparks of life along the way, including a proper blast of hopefulness in the end.

cert 15 themes, violence, sexuality 15.Dec.24


How to Make Millions Before Grandma Dies  
Review by Rich Cline | 3h/5
How to Make Millions Before Grandma Dies
dir Pat Boonnitipat
scr Pat Boonnitipat, Thodsapon Thiptinnakorn
prd Jira Maligool, Vanridee Pongsittisak
with Putthipong Assaratanakul, Usha Seamkhum, Sarinrat Thomas, Tontawan Tantivejakul, Sanya Kunakorn, Pongsatorn Jongwilas, Duangporn Oapirat, Himawari Tajiri, Wattana Subpakit, Sumalee Suteeratham, Phichai Prommate, Buppa Suttisanon
release Tha 4.Apr.24,
US 13.Sep.24, UK 27.Dec.24
24/Thailand 2h05



Is it streaming?

Assaratanakul and Seamkhum
A gently observational comedy, this Thai film is packed with sparky characters and knowing situations. Even when sentiment surges, filmmaker Pat Boonnitipat keeps everything beautifully understated, allowing the story to resonate beyond the cultural specifics. All of us can identify with the dynamics of generational relationships, especially as depicted here with knowing humour. It's a remarkably warm and involving movie, packed with terrific moments that put life in context.
When Amah (Seamkhum) is diagnosed with cancer, her daughter Sew (Thomas) urges her sullen teen son M (Assaratanakul) to spend more time with Grandma. After dropping in for a visit, M becomes increasingly intrigued by this hilariously cranky old woman. Then his cousin Mui (Tantivejakul) is bequeathed their grandfather's home, and M understands that caring for Grandma might allow him to inherit enough to move out on his own. So he's surprised that their friendship is so genuine. And while his mother and uncles (Kunakorn and Jongwilas) bicker about details, M sticks up for her.
It's engaging to watch M as he begins to understand the things that cause Amah to be stressed out, and he starts taking care of her. He also begins to realise all of the things she has learned over the years, generational knowledge that can help him in life. Their scenes together are beautifully played with an earthy authenticity. So when things begin to feel a bit mushy in the extended final act, the emotions have been earned.

The young Assaratanakul gives a terrific performances, relaxed and realistic as M shifts from his aloof life playing videogames and develops a sharp understanding about his whole family, unaware that Amah is teaching him. And she is of course learning from him as well. Seamkhum fills the screen with heart and wit. Her dignity in a scene when she is cruelly dismissed by her brother (Subpakit) is powerfully moving.

"You think of Amah as an asset," Mui tells him at one point. "That hurts," M replies. "But is it wrong?" She reminds him that the only thing old people want from their offspring is time, which is something most families forget. The point here is that as M sets out to play the role of dutiful grandson, his motives are irrelevant, because he ultimately becomes a dutiful grandson, and even more than that. So where the film goes is both bittersweet and hopeful.

cert 12 themes, language 24.Dec.24


Send Shadows your reviews!

< < F O R E I G N > >
See also: SHADOWS FILM FESTIVAL

© 2024 by Rich Cline, Shadows on the Wall

HOME | REVIEWS | NEWS | FESTIVAL | AWARDS | Q&A | ABOUT | TALKBACK